Sales Comparison & Direct Comparison Method

Technical Reference

36110  —  Sales Comparison & Direct Comparison Method

Valuation Fundamentals (36100)
1

Overview

Node 36110 addresses the sales comparison method, also known as the direct comparison method, the most widely applied valuation methodology in the Australian residential and broader property market. The method derives an opinion of value by analysing recent sales of comparable properties and adjusting the sale prices achieved for material differences between each comparable property and the subject property.

The method is most reliable where an active and transparent market exists for broadly similar properties, such as established residential dwellings, standard commercial strata units, or vacant residential land. The valuer identifies a set of comparable sales, verifies the sale details, and applies adjustments for differences in factors such as location, land size, building area, condition, and date of sale, before reconciling the adjusted evidence into a single opinion of value or a rate applied per unit of area.

This node serves valuers, lenders, purchasers, and vendors seeking to understand how the most common Australian valuation method operates, complementing the other core methodologies addressed in nodes 36120, 36130, 36140, and 36150.

2

Scope & Boundaries

This node addresses the sales comparison method, including the selection, verification, and adjustment of comparable sales evidence. It does not address the income capitalisation method, addressed in node 36120, the discounted cash flow method, addressed in node 36130, the cost or summation method, addressed in node 36140, or the hypothetical development method, addressed in node 36150.

It does not address the data sources from which comparable sales evidence is sourced, addressed in node 36420, nor the fundamental principles common to all valuation methods, addressed in node 36100.

Scope Note

This node describes the generally applicable principles of the sales comparison method as at the time of writing. The availability and quality of comparable sales evidence, and the adjustments appropriate to a given property, vary by locality and property type and require the judgement of a suitably qualified valuer.

3

Key Concepts

Comparable Sale
A recent sale of a property sufficiently similar to the subject property in location, type, and characteristics to provide reliable market evidence, verified by the valuer as to price, date, and terms of sale.
Adjustment
A quantified addition to or deduction from a comparable sale price to account for a material difference between the comparable property and the subject property, such as land size, building area, or condition, applied to derive an adjusted sale price directly comparable to the subject.
Market Evidence
The body of verified comparable sales data on which the valuer relies in forming an opinion of value, encompassing sale price, date, terms, and the physical and locational attributes of each comparable property.
Rate per Square Metre
A unit rate derived by dividing an adjusted comparable sale price by a measure of area, such as land area or building floor area, commonly applied to reconcile evidence across properties of differing size within the same market segment.
4

Regulatory & Legal Framework

  • Valuation of Land Act
    State Valuers-General
    (state-based, for example the Valuation of Land Act 1916 (NSW) and equivalent legislation in other states) establishes the statutory basis on which market value derived by the sales comparison method is applied for rating and land tax purposes.
  • API/IVSC Professional Practice Standards
    Australian Property Institute & International Valuation Standards Council
    Set the methodological standards governing the selection, verification, and adjustment of comparable sales evidence.
  • Real Property Act 1900 (NSW)
    State land titles registries
    And equivalent state Torrens title legislation provides the registered title and land parcel data that underpins the identification and description of comparable sales used as market evidence.
5

Practical Application

The application of the sales comparison method varies with the depth of the comparable sales market available for the subject property.

ScenarioApplicationOutcome
A suburban house is valued for a mortgage refinanceThe valuer selects three to five comparable sales of similar houses in the same locality and adjusts each for material differencesThe adjusted evidence supports a single opinion of market value for the subject property
A strip of retail shops is valued for an investment saleThe valuer derives a rate per square metre from comparable retail sales in the same trading precinctThe derived rate supports the asking price and informs prospective purchaser negotiations
Vacant residential land is valued to support a construction loanThe valuer selects comparable vacant land sales and adjusts for site attributes including frontage, zoning, and topographyThe derived value supports the lender’s loan-to-value assessment for the construction facility

Findings are presented on the basis of data and evidence alone.